Sudden Anger and Founding a Partial Defense to Murder Essay

Sudden Anger and Founding a Partial Defense to Murder Provocation acts as a partial defence to murder, but only to reduce the conviction to manslaughter. The defence of provocation only becomes relevant when the prosecution can show evidence that proves that the defendant killed the victim with the necessary mens rea for murder, that is ‘an intention to kill or an intention to cause grievously bodily harm’.1 If the jury accepts that the defendant may have been provoked to lose his self control and that a reasonable person may have been provoked to lose his self control and do so as the defendant, they must acquit of murder and convict of manslaughter. This is known as the subjective and objective†¦show more content†¦The alleged provocation was that a neighbour she was visiting produced a knife but not in a threatening way, but enough so to make her lose her self control, she then snatched the knife and stabbed the neighbour to death. The Court of Appeal agreed that it was ‘very difficult in such a case to distinguish between the gravity of the provocation and the accuseds capacity for self-control which had been affected by the psychological stress of the violence she had suffered’. Tipping J., giving one of the majority judgments which held that the New Zealand statute on provocation (section 169 of the Crimes Act 1961) mandated the application of the distinction, said that it required mental gymnastics. 4 In 1994 battered womens syndrome was included for the first time in the British classification of mental diseases. An appeal out of time was allowed in R v Hobson [1998] CA and a retrial ordered to consider the new medical evidence. In this case the defendant stabbed her abusive partner to death in 1992. It was held that battered wife syndrome was a mental disease and could cause abnormality of mind and so a re-trial was ordered Battered woman syndrome was confirmed as a characteristic in R v Smith (Morgan) [2001] HL. In this case the defendant and the victim were alcoholics and friends. During an argument where theShow MoreRelatedLangston Hughes Research Paper25309 Words   |  102 Pagesbetween the woodshed and outhouse. Kansas farmers planted the winged seeds for shade trees. He also delivered the Saturday Evening Post and the Lawrence Democrat. With the money, he hoped to buy new boots. Instead, Grandmother Mary used it to make a partial payment on the mortgage. To Langston, the word mortgage seemed almost as bad as the words slavery or Jim Crow Laws, the rules of segregation that kept him and other blacks from using public restrooms or drinking from public fountains, entering certainRead MoreStephen P. Robbins Timothy A. Judge (2011) Organizational Behaviour 15th Edition New Jersey: Prentice Hall393164 Words   |  1573 PagesNegotiations 467 Summary and Implications for Managers 469 S A L Self-Assessment Library What’s My Preferred Conflict-Handling Style? 446 Myth or Science? â€Å"Communicating Well Is More Important in Cross-Cultural Negotiations† 462 glOBalization! Anger and Conflict Across Cultures 467 Self-Assessment Library What’s My Negotiating Style? 467 An Ethical Choice Using Empathy to Negotiate More Ethically 468 Point/Counterpoint Player–Owner Disputes Are Unnecessary 471 Questions for Review 472 ExperientialRead MoreProject Mgmt296381 Words   |  1186 Pagesbuilding collaborative relationships among a diverse cast of characters. Exciting opportunities await people skilled in project management. The project approach has long been the style of doing business in the construction industry, U.S. Department of Defense contracts, and Hollywood as well as big consulting firms. Now project management has spread to all avenues of work. Today, project teams carry out everything from port expansions to hospital restructuring to upgrading information systems. They areRead MoreOcd - Symptoms, Causes, Treatment131367 Words   |  526 PagesNew Brunswick, Canada. He received his PhD from the In stitute of Psychiatry, University of London, England. Dr. Clark has published numerous articles on cognitive theory and therapy of depression and obsessive–compulsive disorders (OCD), and is a Founding Fellow of the Academy of Cognitive Therapy. He is coauthor, with Aaron T. Beck, of Scientific Foundations of Cognitive Theory and Therapy of Depression and coeditor, with Mark Reinecke, of Cognitive Therapy across the Lifespan: Evidence and PracticeRead MoreRastafarian79520 Words   |  319 PagesRastafarianism is a deeply patriarchal religion that remains completely behoven to the Bible. 10. For the Rasta, the land mass of Africa, one of the poorest continents on earth, is the promised land. 11. Finally, Rastas seem to harbor a great deal of anger against white people, and yet the religion is accepted and popular among some white people. Most non-Rastafarians tend to be puzzled by the movement. And yet there is little question that it has come to deï ¬ ne Jamaican culture in ways that few peopleRead MoreStrategic Human Resource Management View.Pdf Uploaded Successfully133347 Words   |  534 Pagesdifferent settings. From a strategic perspective, a major advantage is that such programs develop a pool of managers who have been exposed to an area of the business who can then provide management talent in the event that there is an unexpected or sudden increase in the level of Page 23 STRATEGIC HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Section One business in that area. Such rotational programs are also widely used for high-potential or fast-track managerial personnel.36 Conversely, the disadvantages of